No Child Left Behind: Making the Most of Options for IDEA-eligible Students
If a Title I school repeatedly underperforms, federal law provides opportunities for students to change schools or obtain additional instructional support. This parent advocacy brief looks at the information parents of students with disabilities need to know and understand in order to maximize these options.
In this article:
The Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA) is the nation's major federal law related to education in grades pre-kindergarten through high school. In its most recent Congressional reauthorization, ESEA became known as the No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) of 2001.
NCLB requires all schools to bring all students to a proficient level in reading and math by 2014. This goal is reached through annual progress targets and measurable objectives for student progress. Measured through annual testing at certain grades, student performance determines whether a school achieves "adequate yearly progress" or AYP.
NCLB introduced several important provisions that provide opportunities for students attending Title I schools to change schools or obtain additional instructional support while their schools improve its performance. Students with disabilities have the same rights to these opportunities as students without disabilities. The information that parents of students with disabilities need to know and understand in order to maximize these options is the focus of this parent advocacy brief.
Understanding students options
- Offer all children in the school, including special education students, the opportunity to attend a school that has satisfactorily achieved AYP. If such a school does not exist within the same school district, NCLB encourages districts to seek cooperative agreements with neighboring districts or offer students supplemental educational services to help improve their academic performance. (Priority must be given to the lowest achieving, low income students.)
- Supply all parents with a list of all public schools, including public charter schools, that the parent can select, and describe the performance and overall quality of those schools.
- Offer students with disabilities, including those with learning and other disabilities, school choice opportunities just as is required for non-disabled students. However, the choices offered to a student with a disability need not be the same as those for non-disabled students, and in making decisions about school offerings, school districts may match the abilities and needs of students with schools. Districts may limit the choice options to those schools that have the ability to provide a free, appropriate public education. However, as part of the required notice to parents, districts must explain why the choices made available to them may have been limited.
Note: Schools must also offer transfer options to students when the school is determined to be "persistently dangerous" and/or a student becomes the victim of a violent crime at a school
Important points about school choice
- The student's school of origin must provide transportation to the new school at no cost. The new school must ensure that the student is able to participate fully in the school, including extracurricular activities.
- Students must be permitted to remain in a new school until they have completed the highest grade in the school; however, if and when the school of origin is no longer identified as "in need of improvement" it is no longer required to provide student transportation.
Questions to ask when deciding to change schools
- How are students performing?
Pay particular attention to the performance of subgroups, such as special education students. Special education services should enable students with disabilities to access grade level content standards and perform satisfactorily on district and state assessments.
- How are the students with diverse learning needs (e.g., students with disabilities and students with limited English proficiency) treated?
Students with special needs should be fully integrated in the school environment, including extracurricular activities, and treated with the same respect as all other students in the school. Studies have shown that the more isolated special needs students are, the less access they have to the general curriculum.
- Are the teachers highly qualified to teach in their subject areas?
Are special education teachers qualified in both special education and the subjects they teach? Become familiar with the requirements for teacher quality as required by NCLB and IDEA. Also, be sure that all teachers meet the qualifications, including special education teachers. If your child is experiencing difficulty in reading, check the availability and training of reading specialists trained in the essential components of reading instruction as defined by NCLB. (See the companion publications on page 8 for more information.)
- Do teachers have the skills and knowledge to teach students with special learning needs?
Ask if general education teachers are provided with professional development that helps them understand the needs of students with disabilities, such as learning disabilities. Since most students with disabilities spend much of their instructional time in general education classrooms, this type of training is critical to student success.
- Are specialized staff available to address the special learning needs of a child (e.g., speech therapist, psychologist or aides)?
Confirm that the school has the staff to deliver all specialized and related services needed by your child. Related service providers should work in a collaborative manner with general and special education teachers to foster student success.
- How far is the student willing to be bused?
If your child has special health or behavioral issues, a lengthy bus ride to and from a new school may be troublesome. If your child requires special transportation, confirm that it will be provided at no cost to you.
- Does the student want to be in a school with his or her friends?
If your child has established close friendships, a change in schools may be difficult. Consider if the gains of a new school will outweigh the loss of friendships for your child. An unhappy student is generally not a successful student.
Students with Individualized Education Programs (IEP)
Before making a final decision to change schools, be sure to visit the prospective school and discuss the student's specific needs with the school's staff. A review of the student's current Individualized Education Program (IEP) would be a good way to determine if the prospective school is equipped to deliver all necessary special education services, related services and supports.
When changing schools, the receiving school may adopt the existing IEP, in which case no new IEP is required since the move is considered a "change in location," not a "change in placement." This means, however, that the receiving school will execute all aspects of the existing IEP, including all specialized instructional services (including methodologies such as specialized reading programs), related services, participation with non-disabled students, appropriate accommodations, and inclusion in state- and district-wide assessments of student achievement.
If any of the services in the current IEP will change as a result of the school transfer, then the school of choice must convene an IEP team meeting and develop a new IEP that meets the student's needs.
Choosing a school for your child
Choosing a School for Your Child, published by the U.S. Department of Education, offers step-by-step advice on how to choose among the schools available to your child. It identifies important factors you may want to consider before making a decision. Available online at ED.gov.
To obtain print copies in English or Spanish, write: ED Pubs, Education Publications Center, U.S. Department of Education, P.O. Box 1398, Jessup, MD 20794-1398;
Fax: (301) 470-1244;
Call toll-free: 1-877-433-7827 (1-877-4-ED-PUBS). If 877 services are not yet available in your area, call 1-800-872-5327 (1-800-USA-LEARN).
Those who use telecommunications devices for the deaf (TDD) or a teletypewriter (TTY), should call 1-877-576-7734; or order online at www.edpubs.org.
Supplemental educational services
- Offer supplemental educational services (SES), such as academic tutoring, to low income children, including those with disabilities, at no cost to the families. (Low income students are generally those who are eligible for free or reduced-price lunch.) SES instruction must take place outside of the regular school day. (Priority must be given to the lowest achieving, low income students when request for services exceeds availability.)
- Supply parents of eligible students with a list of approved supplemental educational services providers and help parents choose a provider.
- Continue to offer school choice to all enrolled students.
Important points about supplemental educational services
- States must develop a list of approved "providers" of supplemental educational services. Approved providers (which may include individuals or such organizations as educational service agencies, institutions of higher education, faith-based and community-based organizations, or private businesses) must use high-quality, research-based instructional strategies and have a history of success in improving student academic achievement.
- Schools are not required to provide transportation for students to and from service providers. Parents need to ensure their child attends the supplemental services sessions.
- Students should be given services for an extended period of time, preferably the entire school year.
- Once a provider is chosen, a "learning plan" is developed with the SES provider. A learning plan includes specific achievement goals for the student, a description of how the student's progress will be measured, how the student's parents and teachers will be regularly informed of that progress, and a timetable for improving the student's achievement.
- A school district may terminate the services a provider is providing if the provider is unable to meet the student's specific achievement goals and the timetable set out in the learning plan. Additionally, parents who are not satisfied with the services their child is receiving may request a new provider.
- When the school makes AYP for 2 consecutive years, they are no longer required to provide these supplemental services.
Students with Individualized Education Programs (IEP)
- Services provided as "supplemental educational services" should be academic in nature and should correspond to the student's area of academic weakness, as measured by the testing required by NCLB.
- Services are in addition to those specialized services required by a student's Individualized Education Program (IEP), yet must be consistent with such services.
- Supplemental educational services providers may not discriminate against students with disabilities (including students covered under Section 504). For students with disabilities, including learning disabilities, supplemental services providers who can provide the necessary accommodations must be available. If no provider is able to make services available with the necessary accommodations , the school district must provide the services, either directly or through a contract.
Important terms to know
- Adequate Yearly Progress (AYP)
Annual improvement that states, school districts, and schools must make each year in order to reach the NCLB goal of having every student proficient by the year 2014. The AYP requirement holds schools accountable for continuous progress in student achievement.
- Public School Choice
Opportunities for students in Title I schools that don't show progress to transfer to another school that is achieving better results for students. Schools must provide transportation for students who transfer.
- Supplemental Educational Services
Opportunities for additional academic assistance for students from low income families in Title I schools that consistently don't show progress. Supplemental services, including tutoring, remediation, after-school programs, and summer school are provided at no cost to parents.
Questions to ask when selecting an SES provider
Note: These questions use reading difficulty as the focus for SES services; however, the same questions would apply to difficulty in math.
- How did you or your company become a provider of SES?
Each SES provider had to complete an application checklist with detailed information about the services provided, evidence that the services work, the qualifications of the instructors and how the services align with the state's educational standards. The State Department of Education analyzed each application and approved providers who met the requirements.
- What are your qualifications/training and the qualifications of your staff?
Depending on the area(s) your child is working on, the instructors may have different qualifications. You should ask about the kind of college and even graduate degree held by the instructors and the experience they have in teaching children to read. The instructor might be a reading specialist or a speech-language pathologist with special training in reading. The instructor should be able to explain the evidence behind the approach(es) used.
- Will you complete any testing on my child? If so, what will it show?
Testing should be designed individually for your child. Some important areas to test related to reading are: reading rate; reading accuracy; reading fluency; sight word identification; decoding skills; phonological awareness skills; working memory; rapid naming; spelling; written language. The provider should obtain information from your child's school about areas of difficulty and look at the identified areas of need on your child's IEP (if s/he has one). The provider should also ask you what specific problems you have observed when your child tries to read and write.
- How will you select the academic goals to work on?
Once testing is completed, the results will help identify the areas of strength and weakness. The information provided by you, the child's teacher(s) and a review of the IEP (if your child has one) will also help identify goals.
- How will the extra help provided by you help my child in school?
The goals selected should be related to the core content areas, specifically for the area(s) your child needs to work on. If your child has an IEP with goals for improving reading and written language skills, the supplemental services should target those areas.
- How will you share information with my child's teacher?
The information provided by the SES provider is confidential. It is probably in your child's best interest if the SES provider shares the results of any testing and the progress reports with the child's school. You will be asked to sign a Release of Information form so this can happen.
- How will I know your work is helping my child make progress?
The instructor should be giving you feedback after each session — as well as intermittently — as the intervention is provided. This will probably be an oral report. You should also expect to receive a written summary at the end of the intervention (or perhaps more frequently) that clearly documents progress on the targeted goals. Look for measurable information (e.g., the child was 60% accurate at the beginning of the period and can now complete the task with 85% accuracy; the child had a standard score of 4 on the initial test and now has a standard score of 6).
About the author
Candace Cortiella is Director of The Advocacy Institute (www.AdvocacyInstitute.org), a nonprofit focused on improving the lives of people with learning disabilities through public policy and other initiatives. She also serves on the Professional Advisory Boards of the National Center for Learning Disabilities and Smart Kids with Learning Disabilities. The mother of a young adult with learning disabilities, she lives in the Washington, D.C. area. The author thanks Nancy Swigert of The Reading Center in Lexington, KY, a state approved SES provider, for her assistance with this publication.
Cortiella, C. (2005) No Child Left Behind: Making the Most of Options for IDEA-eligible Students. A Parent Policy Brief from NCLD.
© 2005 National Center for Learning Disabilities, Inc. All rights reserved. This publication is provided free of charge by the National Center for Learning Disabilities. Wide dissemination is encouraged! Copies may be made and distributed in keeping with the following guidelines: The publication must be reproduced in its entirety, including pages containing information about the author, the National Center for Learning Disabilities, and Schwab Learning. Copies of the publication may not be sold.
Comments and Recommendations